A story all about stories, and why we tell them.
Every so often on Facebook, a tagging Top 10 cycle begins. From listing the 12th word on the 12th sentence on the 12th page of a book that you are currently reading, to a listing of top 10 albums, books, or artists, these tagging cycles are fascinating to me (and I always get new things to read or listen to). I donâ€™t know how many times that Iâ€™ve been tagged in a post and then created my Top 10 albums or books. Most recently, I was tagged in a Top 11 All-Time Influential Albums of My Entire Life. Iâ€™m including the list below:
At the tagging behest of Julian Cook, here are the 11 most influential albums of my entire life. In no particular order:
They Might Be Giants: Flood
XTC: Oranges and Lemons
Peter, Paul, and Mary: The Best of Peter, Paul, and Mary
Cyndi Lauper: She’s So Unusual
Propagandhi: How to Clean Everything
The Velvet Underground: The Velvet Underground
Sarah Vaughan: Live at Mister Kelly’s
Nick Drake: Way to Blue
Camper Van Beethoven: Key Lime Pie
The Cure: Disintegration
Bonus extra: Avail: Dixie
I took the prompt literally, and although I didnâ€™t write this list in any particular order, Iâ€™m going to elaborate on it in chronological order. Because there is most definitely a chronological order.
Peter, Paul, and Mary were my childhood obsession, and my first favorite. I carried their Best Of tape everywhere I went. I listened to it everywhere I could. I drove my parents crazy by playing that tape over and over and over again. It was my introduction to music, to melody, and to storytelling through song. I can still sing most songs on that album. Dragons, racehorses, lemon trees, and jet planes continue to have vivid connotations for me. While Tchaikovsky and Joan Baez were also childhood favorites, Peter, Paul, and Mary were the first.
Then I discovered Cyndi Lauper. Holy shit. Cyndi Lauper and Boy George were my heroes in elementary school. I cannot stress enough how much I adored these people who did what they wanted because it was artistic. Because it was beautiful. They embraced being different, they flaunted their own sense of style. I loved it. I was already a geekling, what with reading The Hobbit in fifth grade. And Cyndi Lauper made it clear that you should embrace who you are, that girls were really cool, and that fun was far better than True Womanhood. And I believed her.
Eighth grade brought XTC and They Might Be Giants. Prior to this, sixth and seventh grades had also brought New Kids on the Block, who I adored throughout the first part of middle school. I wouldnâ€™t call this influential, however, Â as much as tweenal. Iâ€™m not sure how girls now deal with growing up, but fetishsizing a boy band (or girl band) is not a bad way to deal with the sudden onset of puberty. After the initial slump into becoming a teenager, my ears reasserted themselves, but with the profound new knowledge that sex was very much linked to music. I listened to the radio avidly, but found myself drawn to bands that seemed to get less, if any, rotation. People made me tapes. Along with XTC and TMBG, I was introduced to Depeche Mode and Morrissey and REM. I wish I could list all of them as most influential. But XTC showed me a new way of looking at the world and finding meaning in it, and TMBG became my favorite band for similar reasons–and have stayed my favorite band for the last 24 years (for more on TMBG, read the intro to Geek Rock and my chapter â€œThey Might Be Lacanian: They Might Be Giants, Jacques Lacan, and the Rhetoric of Geek Rockâ€).
High school. 9th/10th grade. The Cure and Camper Van Beethoven. More tapes from more people. Again, storytelling through song redefined, rebellion embraced, sonic impact re-assessed. 11th/12th grade: The Velvet Underground and Propagandhi (and Avail fits here as well). The discovery of punk was the culmination of much musical searching, the expression of my anger at society, my thwarted idealism, my discontent. It was a revelation, hence the juxtaposition with VU, who define revelation. There were weeks when all I would listen to was Propagandhi and VU. And other weeks when all I would listen to was CVB and The Cure. I went to local shows (hereâ€™s my nod to Avail, but also Inquisition (now Strike Anywhere), Uphilll Down, Four Walls Falling, Action Patrol, and Fun Size, to name a few) at least every weekend. Music was life.
And music was survival. My high school years were particularly messy because my home life was particularly messy. Not to get too into that here, but music, represented by these four bands (and my local scene), gave me hope, anger, optimism, and faith. And I really needed it.
In college, I discovered Nick Drake. Way to Blue was sitting unobtrusively in a CD rack at a record store called Plan 9, and I bought it. This album was the place where all that hope and anger and optimism and faith was leading. This was a different world, a Narnia of music. I jumped into the wardrobe.
About a year or so after I graduated from college, I discovered jazz, which was yet another door that I didnâ€™t just walk through, I swam through (because, as ee cummings taught me, â€œa poet is a penguin, his wings are to swim withâ€). I summarized my discovery of jazz with Sarah Vaughanâ€™s Live at Mister Kellyâ€™s because it reminds me of scotch, summer nights, and listening to music with my entire consciousness.
And most recently Boris, whose music is an out of body experience. After seeing Boris live on their tour for Noise, I felt my perception of sound shift ever so slightly, my perception of possible, my perception of perception. The sonic shift is, for me, also a visceral shift, a paradigm shift, into new modes of being and sensing. All of these albums, in some way, shifted me, my world, my selfhood.
The element that all of these albums have in common is that they are all lyres. Robertson Davies wrote that â€œthe lyre of Orpheus opened the door to the underworld of feeling.â€ For me, music is a door. Music is growth. Music takes me places beyond myself and teaches me who I am.
And that is why I love these top 10, top 11, top 15 lists on Facebook, because who am I is always changing, and each list I make is a different retrospective map of the path I took to become. Today, I look back from where I am, and see these 12 places I have been that have made me. Tomorrow, or next week, or next month, Iâ€™ll remember different moments, memories, albums, and those will be the ones that I list, that I use to map my selfness. Itâ€™s the act of mapping that is important, the tallying and creating, the shifting of lines and charts, of writing each list out. With each list, each map, we create a narrative of becoming, of being, of defining. We create a moment of who we are in this moment.
And then we move on to the next.